Apparently in the comedy world, the joke known as “The Aristocrats” is one that comedians have told to each other for decades. Paul Provenza and Penn Jillette put a camera in front of 100 comedians (well, 99 comedians and Robin Williams) to tell their version of the joke and their stories related to it. THE ARISTOCRATS is the resulting documentary about that joke, which goes something like this: A family walks into a talent agent and says, “You’ve got to see our act.” The agent asks, “So what do you do?” And the family members engage in vile sex acts with one another. The agent says, “What do you call yourselves?,” to which the father answers, “The Aristocrats!”
The big problem with THE ARISTOCRATS is that the joke itself really isn’t funny. I like the punchline, but I’m not a big fan of the scatalogical. Therefore, if you’re not one trained to burst into laughter whenever a dirty word is uttered, you’re not going to laugh a lot. And I didn’t. However, I was never, ever bored by it.
This isn’t really the joke told 100 times, although you do get it thrown at you a lot, including a wordless version by Billy the Mime and an animated version courtesy of the SOUTH PARK kids. For me, the funny parts were when the joke was flipped, twisted or blended into something new, like Wendy Liebman’s take, Doug Stanhope and Andy Richter’s telling of it to their infant sons, Kevin Pollak performing it as Christopher Walken and (it pains me to write this) Richard Jeni intentional flub. Or the humor came from throwaway lines unrelated to the joke, when Taylor Negron argues how the nation needs comedy “after the tragic events of January 3″ (the day he lost his Visa card).
But Drew Carey, Whoopi Goldberg, Bob Saget, George Carlin, Gilbert Gottfried, Bill Maher, et al.? Stop, I’ve heard that one before.