THE EXORCIST: THE VERSION YOU’VE NEVER SEEN – In either of its forms, THE EXORCIST is one of the best movies ever made, horror or otherwise. But only the re-release version from a few years back has the infamous “spider-walk” scene, in which the possessed Regan runs down the stairs like an arachnid, albeit one that spurts blood. Even though I know it’s coming, it still freaks me out big-time.
JAWS – Just pick any scene in the water involving that shark, from the opening kill to that damn head that pops out at Richard Dreyfuss in the boat. I remember watching this as a kid at home on pay TV and my dad coming up behind me and scaring me at a particularly tense moment. He made me cry. Even separated from that, I still consider this the scariest movie ever made.
POLTERGEIST – Two words: the clown.
THE EXORCIST III – I don’t care what anyone says; this is a great movie. And the middle of it has an excellent crap-your-pants scene when the camera slowly pans down a long hallway of a hospital at night for what seems like five long minutes, when suddenly, a nurse is attacked by someone with hedge clippers. Okay, it doesn’t sound scary, but trust me, it is.
HOUSE ON HAUNTED HILL – This is the list’s most unexpected scare. I never would’ve thought an old William Castle/Vincent Price movie in freaking black and white would contain anything remotely scary, but the shock of seeing the old hag in the basement with milky eyes was just that. As effective as anything else on this list.
DEEP RED – In a masterstroke of misdirection, a quiet scene of ratcheted tension and suspense comes to a head when a ventriloquist’s dummy bursts out of a closet. Not from the middle of the frame, where the camera is focused on, but from the side. What makes it even worse is that the fucker is laughing. Bravo, Dario Argento!
PSYCHO – Nope, not the shower scene, but the one at the end when Norman Bates emerges through the door in drag, holding a butcher knife. What does it for me is the disturbing look on his face. I’d find a photo of it online to show you, but part of me doesn’t want to find it.
THE OTHERS – The best movie Nicole Kidman has made and likely ever will, this old-fashioned haunted house thriller manages to be creepy throughout through little more than sounds. But it’s when her kid shows her the crayon drawing she’s made of “the others” that she’s seen that I get the goosebumps, mostly because of how much the old woman looks like the one from HOUSE ON HAUNTED HILL.
THE FLY – As quaint as it may seem compared to the remake, the original FLY is actually a pretty sick-minded movie, what with the industrial press and all. Its iconic image is the final scene of the fly with the human head about to be eaten by a huge spider. To me, it’s absolutely horrifying, made all the more so because the spider looks so lifelike. I still don’t know how they did it.
THE BLAIR WITCH PROJECT – All the backlash has really diminished the power of this movie. It’s not a great one, but it’s good. People claim it’s boring, but I’d like to think it’s all part of the plan so it smack you over the head with the final image in the basement of that damn old house in the middle of the forest. Never has standing in the corner been so terrifying.